Book Review

The Happiest Girl In The World

The Happiest Girl in the World

  • Author: Alena Dillon
  • Genre: YA Contemporary Fiction
  • Publication Date: April 20, 2021
  • Publisher: William Morrow Paperbacks

CONTENT WARNING: sexual abuse of minors, disordered eating, emotional abuse, use of a racist slur

Rating: 2 out of 5.

For Sera Wheeler, the Olympics are the reason for everything. They’re why she trains thirty hours a week, starves herself to under one hundred pounds, and pops Advil like Tic Tacs. 

They’re why Sera’s mother, Charlene, hungry for glory she never had, rises before dawn to drive her daughter to practice in a different state, and why their family scrimps, saves, and fractures.

They’re why when Sera’s best friend reports the gymnastics doctor to the authority who selects the Olympic team, Sera denies what she knows about his treatments, thus preserving favor. Their friendship shatters. But Sera protected her dream — didn’t she?

Sera doubles down, taping broken toes, numbing torn muscles, and siphoning her family’s resources. Soon she isn’t training for the love of gymnastics; she’s training to make her disloyalty worthwhile, no matter the cost.

After the summer Olympics, I figured this could be an interesting read. However, I wasn’t exactly prepared for how close to the real story this was going to be.

Rather than taking inspiration from the real-life scandal that played out in the news, the author simply grabbed the actual story and inserted two new characters into it, changing the names of Larry Nassar and the Karolyis. But she kept the names of the famous gymnasts the same, and it made me wonder if she had gotten their approval to rehash their stories. 

I did like Sera’s character, and getting to know her internal struggle. Lucy was easy to empathize with, and it was also clear to see that Sera was torn between her only friend and dream and how she was raised to be obedient and trust the adults around her, even when they didn’t have her best interests at heart. 

It’s easy to watch the glamorous gymnasts on our television, performing amazing and flashy moves, without realizing the pain and sacrifice that they go through on a daily basis. This book really made that clear: 

“Gymnasts were trained to be silent. … We performed through pain. We were hungry, but we didn’t eat. We sucked it up. We didn’t complain. We didn’t listen to our bodies or our instincts. That’s why we had coaches. The adults were the experts. They knew better than we did. The movements were too dangerous to risk ignoring the advice of experts. They told us we could trust the doctor, so we did. Simple as that. We trusted him. We smiled for the judges.” 

After reading this, I don’t think I’ll ever look at gymnasts the same way again. And it doesn’t just take a toll on the girls themselves, but on the families and people who love them. Sera’s family pays a heavy price for her dreams. 

I can’t help but think that this story could have been great if the author had let her creativity flow a bit more. I wish that she had used the real story as inspiration rather than an outline, and I think I would have really been able to immerse myself more fully. 

10 replies »

      • It definitely is messed up that this happens. And I honestly thought that the book would be more of a fictional spin on the real events, not basically a retelling of the real events with some new characters added. It kind of feels disrespectful to the gymnasts who lived through it to have their names added to this story – I wonder if the author got their permission, you know?

        Like

      • Yes, definitely. I mean, permission or not, I think it’s weird to tell it as fiction. This belongs in an autobiography or biography section. When it’s fictionalized, the author must be taking some liberties when talking about the feelings and experiences of the people involved. It can’t possible be accurate on all counts.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to Evelina @ AvalinahsBooks Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s