Sunday Bookish Discussion

Sunday Bookish Discussion — Five Star Reads

Photo by cottonbro studio on Pexels.com

Finally I get to post a weekly update that is positive! It feels like I’ve been waiting a long time, but things are getting better. I still need the heating pad and a lot of rest, but with the heat, massage, rest, and stretches I’ve been doing are finally starting to relieve the sciatica. It isn’t anywhere near as intense as it was when it started, and I’m incredibly grateful for that.

Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links, and I may earn a small commission at no cost to you if you purchase through my links.

Mom is also doing better, although I still have to work hard to get her to rest. I also have to take my own advice and be as gentle with myself as I am with her—we both need to rest and relax for optimal functioning, so that’s the aim for this upcoming week. We both have a pretty busy week ahead of us, but it is all appointments to care for our physical and mental health. As I write this, I’m incredibly grateful to Amazon, which is a lifesaver for people with problems getting to or around the store. I currently have a subscription to Amazon Fresh, and for only $5 a month it lets me get free delivery, which totally pays off since grocery delivery from local supermarkets or Instacart costs more than three times that, per trip. Most of the time, I can get a same day delivery at no cost. You can learn more about this program here.

This week I want to open the floor to chat about what turns books into five star reads for us. I am aware that reading is a subjective experience, and how we feel about them is a completely unique experience. In fact, how I experience the same book can change so much on so many factors, including my own emotional state. 

But today, I want to hear from you all about what elevates a book into a five star read. I’m hoping to get a lot of opinions, just in case I ever decide to fulfill my dreams of becoming an author. I’ll start by sharing my own ideas. For a book to be a five-star read, it has to be engrossing and well-crafted, as well as having at least one character that I can connect with (see, subjective), showing character growth, and having a decent plot instead of ‘just vibes.’ Additionally, if I listen to it as an audiobook, the narrator has to have a voice that doesn’t grate on my nerves, and should be able to properly pronounce any foreign words in the book. For nonfiction, my criteria include having a fascinating story, telling it in a way where it doesn’t read like a textbook or nonfiction story, and being able to verify the claims they make with peer-reviewed or historical sources listed in a bibliography or appendix.

What elevates a book to a five star read for you?

4 replies »

  1. All of things you mention definitely feed into a 5-star rating, but often there’s also just that almost indefinable ‘feeling’ as well. A book can have all the positive things and still not get 5 stars, I just need the mysterious alchemy to kick in as well!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I’d it’s fiction, a five star read must evoke several emotions from me. Not just happiness. I need a little bit of a roller coaster. For nonfiction, I’m looking for three or more takeaways that I can apply to my life. Even if an autobiography (which I rarely read), I wouldn’t pick it up if it weren’t from someone I admire and potentially has something to share that I might want to emulate.

    Liked by 1 person

    • That sounds reasonable. I love a little bit of a rollercoaster as well, and can’t justify a five star rating unless the MC shows at least some growth. Also, I love that you search for takeaways to apply the info to your life, that is such a mindful way to read nonfiction. I might have to adopt that!

      Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.